Students will take notes, compare and contrast using a v. Tell students that today they will read another version of the story cinderella. The cinderella story is told in many different ways by people from many different cultures. For years, the classic cinderella story has been adapted for television, books, and, of course, films. Adorable penguins act as the main characters in this silly fractured fairy tale. Comparing and contrasting different versions of a story sas. Comparing 6 versions of the popular disney princess. There are between 350 and 1500 different versions of. Different versions of cinderella can be found as movies, books, plays, and poems. They can be found in more parts of the world, told in more languages, and in more different ways than any other folktale. First, id like to mention that i actually really loved the new 2015 liveaction version of cinderella. Big idea using different versions of cinderella stories provides a chance for students to experience the same story yet be exposed to different cultures.
The male version of the cinderella story this cinderella fractured fairy tale is a charming spoof. Do you teach about fairytales or different versions of the classic cinderella story. An authors note includes information on the collector of many zuni folktales. They originated from the most popular version written in french by charles perrault written in 1607. From china to england, we will explore different versions of the tale from around the world. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading cinderella. Charles perraults cinderella, or the little glass slipper. What the story of cinderella looks like in 9 countries around. The book is beautifully illustrated and cinderella is a favorite story of all girls, young and old. It can easily be reused with different versions of the cinderella story. The first version is written as a poem by roald dahl and the second version is a fictional story by brothers grimm. Aug 16, 2010 i will now be comparing 3 different versions of cinderella in which i compare the original 1988 black diamond classics vhs, the 1995 masterpiece collection vhs, and the 2005 2disc platinum. Many countries and cultures have their own version of the familiar story. Swbat listen to a version of cinderella and then complete a chart noting different elements of the story.
Comparing cinderella stories from around the globe this unit is designed to thoroughly address ccs. How many different versions of such popular fairy tales as cinderella and snow white are there. For example, in the persian cinderella we find that the women and girls are confined to a certain section of the house. This lesson will look at the cinderella story throughout history. Cinderella s father remarried and although he was around, her new stepmother and step sisters still managed to treat cinderella poorly. This miniunit includes resources to compare and contrast different versions of the cinderella story. Stories around the world by cari meister is a fabulous resource for multicultural versions of the cinderella story. Cinderella compare and contrast essay 809 words bartleby. Introducing different versions of cinderella colorin colorado. Apr 07, 2015 if youd prefer to have one book, cinderella. Sep 27, 2016 there are so many different versions of cinderella out there. Cinderella is a magical tale that has been told around the world and in many different ways. These cinderella fractured fairy tales are diverse takes on the classic.
However, cinderella, in spite of her mean apparel, was a hundred times more handsome than her sisters, though they were always richly dressed. Billy beg of ireland is just one of many of these versions of the story. Because there are so many different versions, it makes it perfect to use when studying text to text connections. Dec 06, 2015 this is a book trailer depicting twenty different and diverse picture book versions of cinderella stories, with a link to the supporting bibliography. Cinderella 20 different versions book trailer youtube. A father and daughter are caught in a parallel universe where the great queens snow white camryn manheim, cinderella annmargret, and riding hood iii kim thomson have had their kingdoms fragmented by warring trolls, giants, and goblins. Because there are so many different versions of cinderella from around the world, we are privy to those cultures through the story. Cinderella has come a long way from its origins as a tale about persecution and the dangers of systemic oppression. Comparing and contrasting is a higher level thinking skill promoted in the common core standards leading to the ability to comprehend and analyze texts through various topics and genre. This is partly based on the grimm brothers version of cinderella, including the enchanted birds, mothers grave, three balls, and mutilation and blinding of the stepsisters. Athough not the first version of cinderella, disneys 1950 animation is the most well known version.
Reading different versions reinforces the background knowledge hell need to understand these references. The brothers grimm also have a popular, yet more gruesome. Why is there so many versions of cinderella answers. How have these stories changed, and how have they remained the same, as they have been interpreted in different cultures and countries. Sep 29, 2016 not only is it perfect to compare and contrast with other versions of cinderella, but it would make a cute book to read during applecider season in the fall.
In most versions the father remarries after a few years when he feels cinderella needs a mother figure. With the help of her fairy god mother, cinderella attended the ball. Three of the most popular versions are little golden book cinderella, the grimm brothers version of cinderella, and the disney 2015 film cinderella. The bulk of the books on this list are not picture books.
Depending on where and when you were brought up, your idea of cinderella may be the disney movie, the fairy tale in grimms fairy tales, the classic fairy tale by charles perrault, upon which the disney movie is based, or one of the other versions of cinderella. The little golden book, the grimm brothers version and the 2015 disney film version of cinderella are all taken from the original story. A curated picture book list featuring a variety of folktales for kids from india. Cinderella is one of the most wellknown stories around the world. Collection of cinderella books retelling the magical tale. They also have to cover their faces when they go out to shop so strangers cannot look at them. Cinderella childrens books are so different from the disney version that most. A bibliography of picture books and novels based on the cinderella theme set around the world. Free comparing cinderella graphic organizers sara j creations. Of all three versions i read, i love disneys one the best.
The cat cinderella the little glass slipper aschenputtel the baba yaga the little glass slipper katie woodencloak tattercoats ashey pelt the sharp grey sheep rashincoatie cap orushes the hearth cat the princess and the golden shoes. Cinderella penguin, or, the little glass flipper by janet perlman. Had their mothers temper, less beautiful than cinderella. The disney animated movie is probably one of the most popular and well known versions of the cinderella fairytale. Here is a list of some of the recent versions of the cinderella fairytale cinderella disney animated movie. One of the most well known was written by jacob and wilhelm grimm the grimm brothers in the 19th century. While the language may be construed as a bit complex, this offers teachers an opportunity to help students expand their vocabulary. They are introduced to a new version of cinderella called cinderelly. The first major difference i ran across actually surprised me.
Youll find versions of the classic tale, versions from around the world, and the story with a. There are so many versions of this iconic storybook heroine. There are over 900 different versions of cinderella stories. A powerful version from the folklore of the algonquin indians. In this classroom clip, albuquerque teacher clara gonzalesespinoza introduces a character study of cinderella by sharing a number of different versions of the cinderella story, chosen to reflect the cultures of her students. The cinderella story lesson plans and teaching ideas.
Mary is a childrens librarian and has wonderful, intelligent writing, and. Comparing different versions of the same story worksheets. Into the woods, a musical with music and lyrics by stephen sondheim and book by james lapine, includes cinderella as one of the many fairytale characters in the plot. Remind the students of all the different versions of cinderella they have read during the past week. I created a free graphic organizer that helps students identify the different parts of the story. This is a book trailer depicting twenty different and diverse picture book versions of cinderella stories, with a link to the supporting bibliography. May 26, 2015 in this one were discussing the combination of the original cinderella and the disney version versus the liveaction disney cinderella. Cinderella stories have been told and retold all over the world. The popularity of his tale was due to his additions to the story, including the pumpkin, the fairygodmother and the introduction of glass slippers. Teaching with cinderella stories from around the world. In this unit, students will be exposed to a variety of different cinderella stories from around the world.
I invite students to meet at our gathering place sitting on the floor at circle time. The male version of the cinderella story this cinderella fractured fairy tale is a. Not only is it perfect to compare and contrast with other versions of cinderella, but it would make a cute book to read during applecider season in the fall. From the iconic disney cartoon to the upcoming remake starring camila cabello, each adaptation features its own unique versions of the storys characters, storylines, and costumes. The first version of cinderella originated in france written by charles perrault in 1697 donahue. Weve created this ultimate list of the best cinderella books for kids to include cinderella adaptations from. Apr 30, 20 today, in part two of our series on fractured fairy tales, were sharing our favorite cinderella fractured fairy tales from a wild west adventure to an egyptian version your students will love. Cinderella, and the disney two different versions of. While there is a kind and beautiful heroine, this cinderella story has many different elements that sets it apart from the story we may be familiar with, and there are not many cinderella around the world stories from africa. Cinderella is a popular fairy tale that may have up to 800 versions. Cinderella is forced to submit to the demands of her stepmother and two step sisters after her fathers death. While the names ashpet, tattercoats, and catskins may be somewhat familiar to you, there seem to be as many different names for the main protagonist as there are different versions of the story.
From 1911 to now, heres how cinderella is different in. The book also bases cinderella s story off of two different royal balls rather than just a single royal ball. These free fairytale storybooks get kids thinking about being outdoors. Compare and contrast two or more versions of the same story e. For example, there are numerous versions of the cinderella story from around the world.
Cinderella around the world stories appear in many cultures, with more than 500 different versions. The book also bases cinderellas story off of two different royal balls rather than just a single royal ball. Introducing different versions of cinderella in this classroom clip, albuquerque teacher clara gonzalesespinoza introduces a character study of cinderella by sharing a number of diverse versions of the cinderella story, chosen to reflect the cultures of her students. Students write a narrativea cinderella variationwith a plot appropriate to the genre and an original setting. Cinderella or the little glass slipper by charles perrault is the version. If you are looking for an excellent way to compare and contrast two different genres, look no further. Reading different childrens book versions of stone soup. What a fun way to compare two versions of the same story this 22 page unit offers vocabulary, reading comprehension strategies, creative writing, poetry, art, and math.
When told she was not allowed to attend the royal ball, her fairy god mother used animals from the house to provide her with travel, she also gave cinderella a brand new dress and slippers. Are many of todays fairy tales pale imitations of the originals. Like many versions from around the globe, kao and the golden fish by wilai punpattanakulcrouch and cheryl hamada includes the central elements of the cinderella story. I will now be comparing 3 different versions of cinderella in which i compare the original 1988 black diamond classics vhs, the 1995 masterpiece collection vhs, and. This version of cinderella by charles perrault would be a fantastic book to read as a read aloud in a 5th grade classroom. Set in a southwest pueblo, this story has a very different ending from the.
So basically its really book and movie vs movie im sorry for totally stretching the lines of the whole book vs movie thing. Ive heard glass slipper, golden sandal by paul fleischman is a good one, too. In this activity, students will read two different versions of cinderella. Compare and contrast versions of a story what story has wicked stepsisters, a fairy godmother, glass slippers, and a girl who works hard and ends up marrying a prince. Free comparing cinderella graphic organizers sara j.
Students can compare the different versions and determine what is the same and what is different. Cinderella stories originated through the oral tradition of storytelling. I ask them to pay attention to what is different or the same in this book compared to the traditional version. The age in the disney version is referred to but there is no mention of age in the grimm tale. The book is based almost solely on what happens at the ball. Lessons and activities that help kids explore story elements, appreciate different cultures, and compare 10 versions of this timeless fairy tale. It was the twelfth walt disney animated movie and was released on february 15, 1950. This story appears in the folklore of many cultures. The roughface girl by rafe martin, mufaros beautiful daughters. Read ashey pelt irish version of cinderella and other irish fairy tales on, reading time. This made cinderella a more beautiful and beloved story. Using different versions of cinderella stories provides a chance for students to experience the same story yet be exposed to different cultures. Plan your 60minute lesson in english language arts or literature with helpful tips from jody barnes. The plans are designed to compare cinderella grimms.
Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Reading more than one version of a story can also be an interesting way to explore different cultures. Every version of cinderella in one beautifully formatted ebook with stunning. The mice added more life to the story and we all love the cartoon of this beloved fairy tale. Mar 23, 2020 19 cinderella stories from around the world books featured multicultural books march 23, 2020 1 comment thienkim lam cinderella, kid lit since she was a toddler, the story of cinderella has been my daughters favorite fairy tale. Whereas the movie has more of a story to it and involves more characters than the book does. To further confuse matters, calling a story a cinderella story does not mean that the heroine is named cinderella. A unjustly neglected protagonist, a wicked stepmother, a fairy godmother and a royal love at a ball relive all the magic or lack thereof of beloved tales many adaptations.
Dating back to the first century, what was once a story about a greek slave girl. Edna who follows a different path but still ends up living happily ever after. That is one of the reasons there are more than 1500 versions of this tale. Review cindy ellena wild western cinderella by susan lowell that was read the previous day by taking a quick picture walk through the book. Any ya or childrens books were added to ya retellings of cinderella or cinderella retellings. There are so many different versions of cinderella out there. This lesson on comparing and contrasting stories will focus on finding similarities and differences in versions of stories that are by different authors from.
1305 880 131 357 459 1379 494 309 934 1458 622 502 1490 128 1085 1427 549 927 1355 1005 42 164 1550 763 1468 232 821 291 863 818 1066 982 917 1149 1450 893 125 906 720